Guide · Gameplay

GTA 6 Choices: Every Decision and What It Changes

GTA Scoop editorial team · Updated · 7 min read
GTA 6 Choices: Every Decision and What It Changes
Official GTA VI artwork · © Rockstar Games

Key facts

  • Most mission choices in GTA 6 change a scene or a payout, not the story
  • Only two late choices decide the ending: Take deal in Protective Custody, and Swim for it or No Surrender in The End of the Road
  • Your Criminal Profiles, relationship and Family Savings decide what Swim for it leads to
  • Accepting Nate's steroids in Making Gainz changes Lucia's look for the rest of the game

As of 21 November 2026, almost every choice in GTA 6 only changes a scene, a payout or an unlock, not where the story goes. The ones that really matter come right at the end: taking the deal in Protective Custody sends you to a separate ending, and Swim for it or No Surrender in The End of the Road decides the rest. What Swim for it leads to depends on how you’ve played, through your Criminal Profile, your relationship level and your Family Savings. Below is every choice we’ve documented, mission by mission, with the best pick.

The choices that change something

Choice Mission What it changes Best pick
Trust Halifax Dubious Provenance Trusting him is what opens the next part of the mission Trust him
Steroids from Nate Making Gainz Accepting changes Lucia’s physique for the rest of the game Decline, unless you want the look
Answer Kordell at the pool Dirty Work The wrong reply fails the mission Follow the walkthrough answer
Kill or spare Felipe Bad Driver! Kill: $20,000. Spare: unlocks Collect Felipe’s Gift (his vehicle) Spare him
Pay Eddie $50,000 Attend Eddie Acosta’s Party Paying only gets you a worthless NFT Refuse
Side with the police or Kyle Buddy? Police side pays $5,000; both count for Strangers & Freaks Police, for the cash
Mr. Mangrove’s fate Help Kirk Find Mr. Mangrove Shooting Mr. Mangrove pays $10,000; any ending counts Your call
Pay $5,000 or steal the van Collect Chemicals for Kyle Cost versus a chase Steal it to save the money
Defuse or provoke the Kolts Girls’ Trip Defusing twice avoids a fight and keeps your profile clean Defuse twice
Take part after knocking out Rodney Safe Word Taking part annoys Lucia Decline
Shoot or Take deal Protective Custody Take deal skips the finale and leads to a separate ending Shoot, for the main endings
Swim for it or No Surrender The End of the Road Decides your ending See the endings guide
Official GTA 6 screenshot of Jason Duval and Lucia Caminos
Jason and Lucia. How you treat people along the way feeds into how their story ends. © Rockstar Games

Choices that don’t change the outcome

These play differently but lead to the same place. Pick whatever you like, though sparing people and talking things down helps keep your Criminal Profile at Professional.

Choice Mission
Kill Arnold or let him go (he’s gone either way) Hey Arnold!
Save Dobbs from the shark or not Island Dreams
Large Bouquet ($10) or Roses ($25) for Lucia Buy Flowers
Help Mario on stage or refuse (both pay $10,000) Afternoon Delight
Hand over the necklace as collateral, if you bought it Overnight Charges
Take Cut or Pure product from Tyrone Dealer’s Choice
Spare Halifax or shoot him at the end (no consequence documented yet) Dubious Provenance
Pay the doorman $20 for a tip, or break in Here, Kitty Kitty
Refuse or hand over the package to the junkie Climbing the Cellerichain
Put Monty back on land or drop him to the alligator The Missing Link
Plant the charges solo or together Hidden Charges
Accept or refuse vape sticks; defuse or not Peach!
A late choice in the spoiler box Brother to Brother
Which cars you pick for Jason and Lucia Company Cars
Which outfit you buy at Doigt d’Or Watch It
Who sits at which VIP table (any group except Maleek Rivers’) Headliners
Lucia’s answers to Kordell on the drive Team Building
Your reply to Kordell when he comes over Blood, Sweat and Gear
Shayna and Raph’s standoff: shoot or talk it down This Is a Free Call From…
Help Mattia get Kat to hospital, or refuse (refusing ends the mission early; one guide counts helping towards your ending, but no effect is confirmed) VC Baby

What decides your ending

Two things work together. First, the late mission choices above: Take deal in Protective Custody is its own ending, and No Surrender at the bridge is another. Second, if you choose Swim for it, the game looks at how you’ve played:

  • Criminal Profiles for both Jason and Lucia. Killing civilians and police drags them down; knockouts, sparing people and staying hidden keep them at Professional.
  • Relationship level between Jason and Lucia, built through dates and time together.
  • Family Savings in BuckMe. The best ending wants $2,000,000 saved (our BuckMe guide explains the account).
  • Money for Tommy. When you’re asked to send money to Lucia’s aunt for Tommy, pay it every time.

Make a manual save before taking Abe’s call that starts Protective Custody, so you can go back and see the other endings. Full breakdowns, with spoilers kept behind a click, are in GTA 6 endings, and every mission is in order in our walkthrough.

Official GTA 6 screenshot of Jason and Lucia together
Jason and Lucia in Leonida. The last two missions decide which ending you see. © Rockstar Games

Quick answers

Do choices matter in GTA 6?

A few do. Most choices change a scene, a reward or an unlock. The ending is decided by Take deal in Protective Custody, Swim for it or No Surrender in The End of the Road, and, for Swim for it, your Criminal Profiles, relationship level and Family Savings.

Should you kill or spare Arnold in GTA 6?

It doesn’t matter for the story: Arnold is gone either way. Letting him go is the cleaner pick for your Criminal Profile.

Should you kill or spare Felipe in GTA 6?

Spare him. Killing him pays $20,000, but sparing him unlocks Collect Felipe’s Gift, which gets you his vehicle.

Should you take the steroids in Making Gainz?

Only if you want Lucia’s new look: accepting changes her physique for the rest of the game. There’s no other reward either way, and declining is the default.

Should you trust Halifax in Dubious Provenance?

Yes. Trusting him is what opens the next part of the mission. You can still shoot or spare him at the end, and no consequence for that has been documented yet.

Which choice gives the best ending in GTA 6?

Choose Shoot in Protective Custody and Swim for it in The End of the Road, with both Criminal Profiles at Professional, the top relationship level and $2,000,000 in Family Savings.

Sources11
Spotted something wrong or out of date?Suggest an editHow we verifyBack to top ↑